The Value of Constitutional Values: With the Examples of the Bavarian and the Indian Constitution

  • Christian A Bauer University of Applied Sciences, Wuerzburg
  • Harald J Bolsinger University of Applied Sciences, Wuerzburg

Abstract

The Bavarian and the Indian constitutions were developed in almost the same period of time. Because of historic experiences the prospect of legal certainty was the determining factor for the representatives of the people in India and Bavaria. They elaborated functioning constitutions and integrated their fundamental ideological principles quite naturally. The Indian and the Bavarian constitution are characterized by their aspirations to balance social injustice, particularly by striking a balance between individual liberty and social need.
The history of political economy demonstrates a broad variety of interpretations regarding the meaning and function of value concepts. When we review all these value concepts we identify two poles of the value-concept that still lack compatibility with each other in economical and philosophical schools to this day. Value systems have to be applied situation-sensitive and are in need of a frequent critical reflection; they need to be refused or changed if necessary.
Examining some examples of the Bavarian Constitution, we indicate some concordances with regard to contents of the Indian Constitutional Law. The equivalences in the Bavarian and the Indian Constitution incorporate entitlements which should protect citizens against an unjustified economical assault upon their existence.

The social value conflicts that occur more and more because of the hiatus to the constitutionally warranted values, and that cannot be solved simply by law or political adjustment, are therefore up for discussion. We then examine the disparity between entitlements and reality and discuss the hierarchy of our values.

Author Biographies

Christian A Bauer, University of Applied Sciences, Wuerzburg

University of Applied Sciences, Wuerzburg, Germany

Harald J Bolsinger, University of Applied Sciences, Wuerzburg

University of Applied Sciences, Wuerzburg, Germany

Published
2014-07-01