Fundamentality and Conditionality of Existence


  • Sahana Rajan University of Delhi, India



In metaphysics, fundamentality is a central theme involving debates on the nature of existents, as wholes. These debates are largely object-oriented in their standpoint and engage with composites or wholes through the mereological notion of compositionality. The ontological significance of the parts overrides that of wholes since the existence and identity of the latter are dependent on that of the former. Broadly, the candidates for fundamental entities are considered to be elementary particles of modern physics (since they appear to play the role of ultimate parts to all phenomena). The paper intends to show the inadequacy of the object-oriented notion of conditionality by pointing out that the parts and wholes possess varying conditions of existence. By alleging that only the parts are ontologically significant is to conflate such conditions and neglect the spectrum of conditions which exist in our world. A proposal for a revised notion of compositionality in terms of structural relatedness is also put forward.


Barrow, J. D. (2014). The origin of the universe. Orion. Retrieved from

Davies, P. (2006). The origin of life. Penguin Books Limited. Retrieved from

De Haro, S. (2018). Relative fundamentality and the metaphysics of emergence. Retrieved from Harrison, E. (2000). Cosmology: The science of the universe. Cambridge University Press. Retrieved from https:// books?id= eFchAw AAQBAJ Holden, T. (2004). The architecture of matter: Galileo to kant. Oxford University Press.

Knight, C. (2018). Origins of society. Retrieved from

Kolb, E. (2018). The early universe. CRC Press. Retrieved from Koslicki, K. (2017). Structure. In Handbook of mereology.

McGinn, C. (2011). Basic structures of reality: Essays in meta-physics. Oxford University Press.

Nave, C. R. (2018). Elementary particle populations. Georgia State University. Retrieved from Petter, P. (2013). Basic knowledge of Astrophysics: A new way. epubli GmbH. Retrieved from books? id=Ne69AQAAQBAJ Runciman, W. G. (2001). The origin of human social institutions. British Academy.

Schmidt, O., & Lebedinsky, A. (2001). A theory of earth’s origin: Four lectures. University Press of the Pacific. Retrieved from Smart, W. M. (2015). The origin of the earth. Cambridge University Press. Retrieved from https:// books? id=0BVEBgAAQBAJ Tahko, T. E. (2018). Fundamentality. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.), The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (Fall 2018). Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University. Thalos, M. (2011). Two conceptions of fundamentality. Philosophy of the Social Sciences,41(2), 151–177.

Turner, J. H., & Maryanski, A. (2015). On the origin of societies by natural selection. Taylor & Francis. Retrieved from Wimsatt, W. C. (2000). Emergence as non-aggregativity and the biases of reductionisms. Foundations of Science, 5(3), 269–297.




How to Cite

Rajan, S. (2019). Fundamentality and Conditionality of Existence. Tattva Journal of Philosophy, 11(2), 1-9.