Analyzing the Need to Reinstate the NGT Ban with Respect to Meghalaya’s Rat-Hole Mines
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.12728/culj.16.2Keywords:
Sixth Schedule, Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957, B.P Katakey Commission, Mines Act, 1952, Acid-Mine DrainageAbstract
On 13th December 2018, 15 miners were trapped in a rat-hole mine in the East Jaintia Hills District of Meghalaya. This incident happened despite the ban imposed and the detailed guidelines laid down by the National Green Tribunal (NGT) in 2014, in response to the South Garo Hills incident. As of date, no concrete legislative measures have been implemented by the State Government of Meghalaya, nor by the respective autonomous District Councils to regulate coal-mining. Clothed with the protection conferred by the Sixth Schedule, the State harbors rampant scientific mining practices, and its administration argues that it is a necessity for the economic development of the State. As a result, agriculture has been brought to a standstill and the coal mafia plaguing the State has received an added impetus. Rehabilitation of citizens remains a distant dream and the Sixth Schedule protection afforded to the State, facilitates exploitation instead of protecting the masses. This article will argue strongly for the continuation of the NGT Ban and analyze and counter popular arguments that have been presented for the legalization of coal mining in Meghalaya.
References
The Chasnala Mine Disaster (1975). See Editorial, No lessons learnt, THE HINDU (Dec. 27, 2018), https:// www.thehindu.com/ opinion/ editorial/no-lessons-learnt/article25836724.ece; The South Garo Hills Disaster (2012). See Sushanta Talukdar, For days on end, 15 workers trapped in Meghalaya rat-hole coalmine, THE HINDU (July 11, 2012), https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/for-days-on-end-15-workers-trapped-in-meghalaya-rathole-coalmine/ article 3627420.ece; Turamidh Mines Disaster (2016). See Three dead in UCIL’s Turamidh mines mishap,THEHINDUSTAN TIMES (May29, 2016), https://www.hindustantimes.com/nation/three-dead-in-ucil-s-turamdih -mines-mishap/story-GbkunlI1rFaZOHs3p6iyLL.html.
Shiv Sahay Singh, India records 377 mine deaths in three years, THE HINDU (Jan. 02, 2019), https://www.thehindu.com/ news/ national/ india-records-377-mine-deaths-in-three-years/article25892356.ece.
Talukdar, supra note 2.
Rathole Mining, ONLINE NEVADA ENCYCLOPEDIA,http:// www. onlinenevada.org/articles/rathole-mining.(last visited on May 25, 2019).
Rahul Karmakar, Meghalaya’s rat hole traps, THE HINDU (Jan. 12, 2019), https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/13-feared - dead -in-meghalaya-coal-mine/article25736100.ece.
Meghalaya mine collapse: What it’s like to work in a ‘rat-hole’ mine, BBC NEWS (Jan. 3, 2019), https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-46734451.
Sushanta Talukdar, Some sub-channels in rat-hole mine may have collapse, says NRDF, THE HINDU (July 05, 2016), https:// www.thehindu.com/ news/national/other-states/some-subchannels-in-rathole-mine-may-have-collapsed-says-ndrf/article3640408.ece 8 Id.
Talukdar, supra note 8
Karmakar, supra note 8
Karmakar, supra note 6; Rahul Karmakar, In Meghalaya flouting the ban on mining, THE HINDU (Dec. 23, 2018), https:// www.thehindu.com/ news/national/other-states/in-meghalaya-where-it-took-15-deaths-for-the-reality-of-illegal-mining-to-hit-hard/article25808466.ece.
CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD, REPORT OF THE COMMITTEE CHAIRED BY FORMER JUSTICE B.P.KATAKEY IN THEMATTER OF THE STATE OF MEGHALAYA VS ALL DIMASA STUDENTS UNION HASAODISTRICT COMMITTEE & ORS 2 (2018), https://cpcb.nic.in/NGT/ Report-NGT- 15.01.2019.pdf. [hereinafter BP KATAKEY COMM’N REPORT].
State of Meghalaya v All Dimasa Students Union, Dima Hasao District Committee, Civil Appeal No. 10729 of 2018 (July 3, 2019) [hereinafter July Order]. See SC verdict on coal mining people’s victory: Meghalaya CM, THE HINDU (Aug. 15, 2019), https://m.timesofindia.com/ india/ sc-verdict-on-coal-mining-peoples-victory-meghalaya-cm/amp_articleshow/70689123.cms
Karmakar, supra note 6.
GEOLOGICAL SURVEY OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF MINES, BULL. SER. A NO. 45, VOL I: COALFIELDS OF NORTH EASTERN INDIA 29 (2ND ED. 2016),https:// www.gsi.gov.in/ webcenter/ portal/ OCBIS/ page169/page1758?_afrLoop=2077299441968697&_adf.ctrl-state=4itznwwon_9#!%40%40%3F_afrLoop%3D2077299441968697%26_adf.ctrl-state%3D4itznwwon_13
kiranmay Sarma, Impact of Coal Mining on Vegetation: A Case Study in Jaintia Hills District of Meghalaya, India 2 (Feb. 03, 2005) (unpublished M.S. dissertation, International Institute for Geo-Information Science and Earth Observation) (on file with India Environment Portal). See Directorate of Mineral Resource, Cottage CoalMining in the State of Meghalaya and its impact on the environment, inENVIRONMENT CONSERVATION AND WASTELAND DEVELOPMENT IN MEGHALAYA (A Gupta & DC Dhar, eds., 2012).
BP KATAKEY COMM’N REPORT, supra note 13, at 2.
Kiranmay Sarma and Pramod K Yadav, Relentless Mining in Meghalaya, India, 1 CONSERVATION SCIENCE 9 (2013). 22 Karmakar, supra note 12.
OP Singh, Impact of Coal Mining on Water Resources and Environment in Meghalaya 253 (2012), https:// www.researchgate.net/ publication/ 303487611_Impact_of_Coal_Mining_on_Water_Resources_and_Environment_in_Meghalaya (last visited May 25 2019); BP KATAKEY COMM’N REPORT, supra note 13, at 4.
BP KATAKEY COMM’N REPORT, supra note 13, at 4. 25 Geological Survey of India, supra note 16.
BP KATAKEY COMM’N REPORT, supra note 13, at 4. See DIRECTORATE OF MINERAL RESOURCES, GOVERNMENT OF MEGHALAYA, TECHNICAL REPORT OF THE DIRECTORATE OF MINERAL RESOURCES (1985).
PK Guha Roy, Coal Mining in Meghalaya and its impact on environment, 4 EXPOSURE 31-33 (1991).
Kiranmay Sarma, Coal Mining and its impact on Environment of Nokrek Biosphere Reserve, Meghalaya 7 (2002) (unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, North-Eastern Hill University) (on file with North-Eastern Hill University). 30 Geological Survey of India, supra note 17, at 1. 31 KiranmaySarma, supra note 30, at 6. See Directorate of Mineral Resource, supra note 17
Hope of greening the ravaged land, THE SHILLONG TIMES (April 30, 2014), http://www.theshillongtimes.com/2014/04/30/hope-of-greening-the-ravaged-land/ 33 KiranmaySarma, supra note 17; Directorate of Mineral Resources, supra note 17. 34 See WALTER FERNANDES, MELVILLE PEREIRA & VIZELENU KHATSO, NAT’L COMM’N FOR WOMEN, CUSTOMARY LAWS IN NORTH EAST INDIA: IMPACT ON WOMEN (2005).35 Id. See MP Bezbaruah, Land Tenure System in North East India: A Constraint for Bank Financing?, 8(3) DIALOGUE (2007). 36 Threat to life arising out of coal mining in South Garo Hills District v State of Meghalaya, Original Application No, 110(THC)/2012, p.9 (dated 04th January 2019). 37 KiranmaySarma, Impact of Coal Mining on Vegetation: A Case Study in Jaintia Hills District of Meghalaya, India 2 (Feb. 03, 2005) (unpublished M.S. dissertation, International Institute for Geo-Information Science and Earth Observation) (on file with India Environment Portal). See F.G Bell, S.E.T Bullock, T.F.J. Halbich& P Lindsey, Environmental Impacts Associated with an abandoned mine in the Witbank Coalfield, South Africa, 45 INT’L JOURNAL OF COAL GEOLOGY 195-216 (2001). 38 State of Meghalaya v. All Dimasa Students Union Dima Hasao Dist. Committee, Original Application No. 73 of 2014 & Original Application No. 13 of 2014 & Original Application No. 110 (THC) / 2012 6-9 (Aug. 1 2014, Oct. 7 2014; Nov. 12 2014; Mar. 25, 2015); Threat to Life Arising Out of Coal Mining in South Garo Hills District v State of Meghalaya, Original Application No. 110 (THC)/2012 4 (Aug. 31, 2018; Jan. 04, 2019; April11, 2019).39 Threat to life arising out of coal mining in South Garo Hills District v State of Meghalaya, Original Application No, 110(THC)/2012 10 (Jan. 04, 2019) [hereinafter January Order]. See BP KATAKEY COMM’N REPORT, supra note 13, at 39-41. 40 January Order, supra note 40, at 10. 41 Id. 42 BP KATAKEY COMM’N REPORT, supra note 13, at 21. 43 Id. 44 Lamsuk Nongtdu& Dr. Mimi Das Saikia, Effect of Coal Mining in Water Quality of Prang River and LynriangRiver, Jaintia Hills, Meghalaya, India, 5(6) INT’L RESEARCH JOURNAL OF ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY 3179 (2018). 45 OP Singh, supra note 24, at 255.
See A tragedy that was long in the making, THE HINDU (Jan. 25, 2019), https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/a-tragedy-that-was-long-in-the-making/article26082607.ece.47 OP Singh, supra note46 48 See MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT AND FORESTS, STATE OF ENVIRONMENT REPORT, MEGHALAYA 29 (2005), http:// moef.gov.in/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/SoE-report-of-Meghalaya_0.pdf 49 Pramod K Yadav, supra note 22. See H Nath, Environmental Impact on coal mining with special reference to water pollution in Jaintia Hills, Meghalaya, in ENVIRONMENT CONSERVATION AND WASTELAND DEVELOPMENT IN MEGHALAYA 22-32 (A Gupta & DC Dhar, eds., 2012). 50 BP KATAKEY COMM’N REPORT, supra note 13, at 21. 51 See A.D. BRADSHAW AND M.J. CHADWICK, THE RESTORATION OF LAND.THE ECOLOGY ANDRECLAMATION OF DERELICT AND DEGRADED LAND 363-384 (1ST ED. 1980); KJ Chadwick, Methods ofAssessment of Acid Colliery Spoils as a Medium for Plant Growth, in ECOLOGY AND RECLAMATION OF DEVASTATED LAND 81-91 (R.J Hutnik and G Davis, eds., 1973). 52 KiranmaySarma, supra note 17, at 5. See P.A. Constigan, A.D.Bradshaw and RP Gemmel, The Reclamation of Acidic Colliery Spoils, 21(1) JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY 401-409 (1984). 53 Pramod K Yadav, supra note 22, at 6. See T Lyngdoh, Community Dynamics and Edaphic Changes in Relation to Coal Mining in Jaintia Hills, Meghalaya (2011) (unpublished Ph.D. Thesis, North Eastern University) (on file with the North Eastern University).54 Pramod K Yadav, supra note 22, at 6. See KiranmaySarma, RK Rai & SK Barik, Impact of Coal mining on vegetation of Nokrek Biosphere Reserve, Meghalaya, in MINING ENVIRONMENT: PROBLEMS & REMEDIES 77 – 104 (OP Singh, ed., 2005). 55 OP Singh, supra note 24. See S Gupta Das, B.K.Tiwari&R.S. Tripathi, Coal Mining in Jaintia Hills, Meghalaya: An Ecological Perspective in JAINTIA HILLS, A MEGHALAYA TRIBE: ITS ENVIRONMENT, LAND AND PEOPLE 121-128 (P.M. Passah and A.S. Sarma, eds., 2002 ). 56 Talukdar, supra note 7. 57 Id. 58 Id. 59 Karmarkar, supra note 5 60 Id 61 Talukdar, supra note 762 Rahul Karmakar, Meghalaya’s coal mines are used for disposing bodies too, THE HINDU (Jan. 21, 2019), https:// www.thehindu.com/ news/ national/other-states/meghalayas-coalmines-are-body-disposal-pits-too/article26044212.ece 63 Id 64 Id; Karmakar, supra note 5.
Navy Robot located body in Meghalaya mine, THE HINDU (Jan. 18, 2019),https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/body-of-one-of-15 trapped- meghalaya- miners-found-by-naval-divers/article26010931.ece. 66 See BP KATAKEY COMM’N REPORT, supra note 13, at 40. 67 See Karmakar, supra note 5.68 Meghalaya CM pushes for regulated coal mining, THE HINDU (Jan. 19, 2019), https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/ meghalaya-cm-pushes-for-regulated-coal-mining/article26030691.ece[hereinafter Meghalaya CM] 69 Legalise Coal mining in Meghalaya, THE HINDU, Dec. 30, 2018, at 9.
It is a question of livelihood: Owners, THE HINDU (Jan. 7, 2019), https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/it-is-a-question-of-livelihood-owners/article25934581.ece 71 Meghalaya CM, supra note69. 72 Id.
State of Meghalaya v. All Dimasa Students Union Dima Hasao Dist. Committee, Original Application No. 73 of 2014 & Original ApplicationNo. 13 of 2014 & Original Application No. 110 (THC) / 2012 14 (Aug. 1 2014) [hereinafter August Order]. 74 Id. at5. 75 Id. at5. 76 Id 77 Id at 10 78 State of Meghalaya v. All Dimasa Students Union Dima Hasao Dist. Committee, Original Application No. 73 of 2014 & Original Application No. 13 of 2014 & Original Application No. 110 (THC) / 2012 5 (Oct. 7, 2014) [hereinafter October Order].79 Id 80 State of Meghalaya v. All Dimasa Students Union Dima Hasao Dist. Committee, Original Application No. 73 of 2014 & Original Application No. 13 of 2014 & Original Application No. 110 (THC) / 2012 12 (Mar. 25, 2015) [hereinafter March Order]. 81 Id. 82 January Order, supra note 40, at 12. 83 August Order, supra note 74, at10. 84 January Order, supra note 40, at6.85 Id at 10. 86 August Order, supra note 74, at 14. 87 October Order, supra note 79, at 9. 88 Id. 89 March Order, supra note 81, at 6.90 Id at 7. 91 Id 92 Threat to Life Arising Out of Coal Mining in South Garo Hills District v State of Meghalaya, Original Application No. 110 (THC)/2012 4 (Aug. 31, 2018).93 January Order, supra note 40, at 4. 94 March Order, supra note 81, at 6.95 Chandra Bhushan, Rat-hole coal mining must be discontinued, DOWN TOEARTH (Mar. 04, 2019), https:// www.downtoearth.org.in / blog/mining/-rat-hole-coal-mining-must-be-discontinued--63253. 96 BP KATAKEY COMM’N REPORT, supra note 13, at2. 97 Id. See Pramod K Yadav, supra note 22, at 6. 98 Chandra Bhushan, supra note 97; Patricia Mukhim, A Tragedy that was long in the making, THE HINDU (Jan. 25, 2019), https:// www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/a-tragedy-that-was-long-in-the-making/article26082607.ece.99 Hope of greening the ravaged land, THE SHILLONG TIMES (Apr. 30, 2014), http://www.theshillongtimes.com/2014/04/30/hope-of-greening-the-ravaged-land/. [hereinafter Hope of greening the ravaged land] 100 August Order, supra note 74, at 12. 101 January Order, supra note 40, at 4. 102 Id. 103 Hope of greening the ravaged land, supra note 102. 104 Meghalaya CM, supra note 69.105 October Order, supra note 79, at 6. 106 July Order, supra note 15, at 102. 107 Id. 108 ARVIND P. DATAR, COMMENTARY ON THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA 2132 (2nd ed. 2010). 109 Id. 110 See The Repealing and Amending (Second) Act, First Schedule (2017). 111 Karmakar, supra note 12. 112 Meghalaya CM, supra note 69.113 Id. 114 State of Environment Report, supra note 49, at 5. 115 DIRECTORATE OF ECONOMICS AND STATISTICS, MEGHALAYA SOCIO-ECONOMIC REVIEW 26 (2003). 116 Id. 117 See Karmakar, supra note 5 118 Id.
Rahul Karmakar, Lack of Jobs, debts push villagers to illegal coal mines, THE HINDU (Jan. 08, 2019), https:// www.thehindu.com/ news/ national/other-states/miners-overlooked-risks-for-higher-pay/article25934565.ece.120 January Order, supra note 40, at 16. See NGT slaps ₹100 cr fine, THE HINDU (Jan. 05, 2019), https://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/energy-and-environment/illegal-mining-ngt-slaps-100cr-fine-on-meghalaya/article25914767.ece 121 Threat to life arising out of coal mining in South Garo Hills District v State of Meghalaya, Original Application No, 110(THC)/2012 6 (Apr. 11, 2019).122 January Order, supra note 40, at 6. See BP KATAKEY COMM’N REPORT, supra note 13, at 40. 123 STATE OF ENVIRONMENT REPORT, supra note 49, at 28. 124 See The Repealing and Amending (Second) Act, First Schedule (2017).125 Independent Regulator for Coal Sector, PRESS INFORMATION BUREAU (Apr. 27, 2015), http:// pib.nic.in/ newsite/ Print Release. aspx?relid=119748. 126 See The Coal Regulatory Authority Bill, Section 18 (2013). 127 Id.128 Rahul Karmakar, Lack of Jobs, debts push villagers to illegal coal mines, THE HINDU (Jan. 8, 2019), https:// www.thehindu.com/ news/national/other-states/miners-overlooked-risks-for-higher-pay/article25934565.ece. 129 Meghalaya mine collapse, supra note 7. 130 BP KATAKEY COMM’N REPORT, supra note 13, at 2.
Rat-hole mining rampant in Meghalaya despite the NGT ban, THE ECONOMIC TIMES (Dec. 25, 2018), https:// economictimes .indiatimes. com/ news/ politics-and-nation/rat-hole-mining- rampant -in-meghalaya-despite-ngt-ban/articleshow/67242097.cms 132 March Order, supra note 81, at 6.133 MINISTRY OF MINES, Proceedings of the workshop on “Remediation of Mined – Out and Abandoned Mines– Status and Strategies” (Dec. 19, 2016),https:// mines.gov.in/ writereaddata/ UploadFile/ proceedings5.pdf.
